Meteo Sorrento (Amalfi Coast) in novembre

A Naples resident confirms the reputation and then complicates it: "it's true that November is often the most rainy month of the year," with "average temperatures in November usually ranging from 8° to 20°C." But year to year it barely holds — "in the last years we had some hot Novembers with scarce rain and some cool, not too cool, Novembers with a lot of rain." Nobody on the thread described all-day rain, and the question that prompted it — whether Pompeii would be a washout — was answered by checking the forecast nearer the time rather than by writing the month off. Our record is at the wet end of his description and worth knowing before booking: 294mm across 18.6 rain days, the year's highest, with 17.6°C days and the sea still at 20°C.

Sorrento-forum threads on February weather confirm it's still deep winter here, one of the coldest and wettest months of the year, though posters are consistent it's rarely miserable for a full stay - one visitor logged rain on just one or two days out of ten, with a couple of bright enough days to dine outdoors in the evening, jackets on but genuinely pleasant. Daytime temperatures generally sit in the comfortable range for a coat-and-scarf walk rather than anything harsh. Wind is called a real feature of the month, worth a windproof layer regardless of the temperature reading. Some beachfront cafes and the harbor stay closed for the season, but the main tourist sights and most restaurants in town remain open and running normally. Regulars call it a genuinely quiet, low-cost month for anyone not chasing sun. The record: 14.7C days feeling like 12C, 10.4C nights, 107mm across 9.6 days, a 14.9C sea, 74 percent humidity and 8.2 hours of sun.

Sorrento-forum threads on whether it's worth visiting in December land firmly on yes, with caveats: cold but not miserable, sunny stretches genuinely possible, though the region's downpours are called legendary when they do arrive, worth keeping an eye on the forecast before planning a Capri or coastal-village day trip. Posters describe daytime temperatures in the high 50s Fahrenheit with much cooler nights, and the town itself leans into the season - both Sorrento and Naples decked out for Christmas, a real draw in its own right. The trade-off for the good rates and thin crowds is that plenty of pavement cafes and restaurants close for the winter, staff largely gone since late October, so dining runs leaner than in summer. Regulars recommend checking forecasts a couple of days out and keeping a backup plan for any coastal excursion. The record: 15.3C days feeling like 13C, 11.8C nights, 144mm across 11.5 days, an 18C sea, 74 percent humidity and just 6.8 hours of sun.

Sorrento-forum threads on April weather describe it as genuinely fickle - one day pouring with grey skies, the next gorgeous and blue, sometimes within the same visit. Regulars call April normally fresh and showery, sunny days pleasant but outnumbered by cooler, damper ones, and evenings cold enough that a jacket is non-negotiable even after a warm afternoon. The standing packing advice is layers throughout: linen or light trousers with a top for daytime, a proper sweater or cardigan for evenings, plus a real waterproof rather than a light showerproof. Despite the variability, most posters still call April a lovely month overall, just one where a week's stay is likely to see both extremes rather than a single settled pattern. The record: 18.8C days feeling closer to 19C, 13.3C nights, 57mm across 9.7 days, a chilly 15.6C sea still too cold for most swimmers, 74 percent humidity and 11.1 hours of sun.

Sorrento-forum threads on September weather call it lovely on balance, sunbathing and shorts-and-tee days with noticeably less humidity than peak summer - genuinely better for sightseeing as a result. The standard packing list includes trousers, a jumper or light jacket for evenings, and a small collapsible umbrella just in case, since there's a fair chance of a shower somewhere in a week-long stay even in a good year. Experiences do vary: one visitor's first ten days saw no clouds at all until day six, while other threads describe a fair chance of showers the whole stay. Posters agree the good weather often runs well into October, not just September. The record: 26.9C days feeling like 29C, 21.7C nights, 113mm across nine days, a 25C sea, 71 percent humidity and 10.5 hours of sun.