Charlotte Amalie vs The Valley: which is better, month by month

Charlotte Amalie beats The Valley in all 12 months — its lead peaks in September (81 vs 60).

Each place is scored under the lens that suits its type — they are different kinds of destination, so the scores are each place at its own best. Comfort is SeasonMap's 0–100 estimate from ERA5 climate normals, not a forecast.

Charlotte Amalie

U.S. Virgin Islands · tropical climate

Best month
January 90/100
Months won
12 of 12

The Valley

Anguilla · tropical climate

Best month
March 79/100
Months won
0 of 12

Charlotte Amalie vs The Valley — all 12 months

MonthCharlotte AmalieThe ValleyWinnerGap
January90Shot, a little rain, clean air78Bhot, dry, clean airCharlotte Amalie12
February89Ahot, a little rain, clean air78Bhot, a little rain, clean airCharlotte Amalie11
March90Shot, a little rain, clean air79Bhot, dry, clean airCharlotte Amalie11
April90Shot, a little rain, clean air76Bhot, a little rain, clean airCharlotte Amalie14
May88Ahot, a little rain, clean air72Bhot, a little rain, clean airCharlotte Amalie16
June86Asweltering, a little rain, clean air70Bsweltering, a little rain, clean airCharlotte Amalie16
July83Asweltering, rainy, muggy air65Csweltering, a little rain, muggy airCharlotte Amalie18
August81Asweltering, rainy, clean air64Csweltering, rainy, clean airCharlotte Amalie17
September81Asweltering, rainy, clean air60Csweltering, rainy, clean airCharlotte Amalie21
October80Asweltering, rainy, clean air62Csweltering, rainy, clean airCharlotte Amalie18
November78Bhot, rainy, clean air66Chot, rainy, clean airCharlotte Amalie12
December88Ahot, a little rain, clean air74Bhot, a little rain, clean airCharlotte Amalie14

A month is a tie when the two are within 3 points. The widest gap is September (81 vs 60). Tap a month for that month's temperature, rain, humidity and air quality side by side.