Charlotte Amalie vs St. John's: which is better, month by month

St. John's beats Charlotte Amalie in 1 of 12 months — its lead peaks in November (83 vs 78) — and they are within 3 points in December to October.

Each place is scored under the lens that suits its type. Comfort is SeasonMap's 0–100 estimate from ERA5 climate normals, not a forecast.

Charlotte Amalie

U.S. Virgin Islands · tropical climate

Best month: January 90/100
Months won: 0 of 12

St. John's

🇦🇬 Antigua and Barbuda · tropical climate

Best month: March 91/100
Months won: 1 of 12

Charlotte Amalie vs St. John's — all 12 months

Month	Charlotte Amalie	St. John's	Winner	Gap
January	90Shot, a little rain, clean air	90Shot, dry, clean air	Tie	0
February	89Ahot, a little rain, clean air	90Shot, a little rain, clean air	Tie	1
March	90Shot, a little rain, clean air	91Shot, dry, clean air	Tie	1
April	90Shot, a little rain, clean air	90Shot, a little rain, clean air	Tie	0
May	88Ahot, a little rain, clean air	88Ahot, a little rain, clean air	Tie	0
June	86Asweltering, a little rain, clean air	88Asweltering, a little rain, muggy air	Tie	2
July	83Asweltering, rainy, muggy air	84Asweltering, a little rain, muggy air	Tie	1
August	81Asweltering, rainy, clean air	83Asweltering, rainy, clean air	Tie	2
September	81Asweltering, rainy, clean air	80Asweltering, rainy, clean air	Tie	1
October	80Asweltering, rainy, clean air	81Asweltering, rainy, clean air	Tie	1
November	78Bhot, rainy, clean air	83Ahot, rainy, clean air	St. John's	5
December	88Ahot, a little rain, clean air	89Ahot, a little rain, clean air	Tie	1

A month is a tie when the two are within 3 points. The widest gap is November (78 vs 83). Tap a month for that month's temperature, rain, humidity and air quality side by side.